In budgetary matters the PS is bad Council

What grade would you give to the draft budget 2011

15 out of 20. This is "good". This budget is part of an economic policy that allowed the France to cross under the best conditions an exceptional crisis. All the measures taken have this dual concern: accompany growth expectancy, particularly hope that the revival of business investment, and hold the appointment of the euro. In this sense, it's a responsible budget.

The PS j. "unjust" and "insufficient"...

In budgetary matters, the PS is bad Council. He wanted a decrease in VAT and today adversarially, it we reproach of decreased VAT for conservators. In General, the judgment of the Socialists is appalling brutality and remoteness of the realities. With perhaps a flat on renewable energy. It is true that we also, we pose us the question of the effects of boon excess. Import massively panels photovoltaic China does not seem an absolute necessity for the industrial economy French.

The text does fishing not by excess of optimism and lack of ambition in the reduction of the deficits

This budget is "positive realistic." But it is fairly conventional: cannot apply to Ministers of the economy to be realistic negatives. Now, everything depends on the ability of the France to take its place in the wake of German expansion and in emerging markets, which depends on our structures - are not bad - and especially the level of the euro, the dollar and the yuan. I must admit that there is a real question mark. On deficits, on the other hand, there are still two spectacular efforts: the freezing of the competition of the State to local communities, which is not easy, and the continuation of the non-renewal of a departure on retirement, which becomes extremely complicated in administrations. Those who give us lessons of budgetary Puritanism should remember these two evidences.

The plane on tax niches will it enough away Gilles Carrez scoffs a "lime nail...

As soon as it identifies a niche, each think that this is not one to be planing. What was being done isn't so bad. I still wish that those who give lessons to the Ministers and shed their judgment did not forget to take the floor to explain why efforts to taxpayers...

The Liberal you are welcomed to this disguised tax increase

When a niche is emptied of its object, a liberal can only be delighted. A niche is the voluntarism of the State to force the main investment or expenditure in any one sector. While the mathematical result of the abandonment of a niche is the levy increases. But I prefer a neutral levy on investment and expenditure not excessively directory collection.

Do you want some inflections in the review of the text

I especially wanted that we reflect on the taxation of savings. That we put in comparison the performance cost of all forms of fiscal aid and incentives to savings, of Perco to the Scellier, the overseas apart. This "benchmarking", I the fail in this budget. It's a shame: it would perceive that we sometimes spend much for little performance.

Do you want to delete the tax shield and the ISF before 2012

If it is satisfied that a problem, it must also be convinced that it must be resolved quickly. In times of economic crisis and budgetary effort, the implementation of the just sharing between the State and citizens the most active is a tunic of Nessus for the majority. I note also that Nicolas Sarkozy has used, when it was decided to move quickly. Replacing business tax by a modern tax took no more than eleven months, arrested initially. The pension reform, just eight months. 2012, it is in 20 months. It's time for reflection, but it can also be the time of the action. Me, I still support the action.

Members of Parliament, in Committee, refused to extend by four years the Cades lifetime. Do you agree them

Non. Must be spread an exceptional crisis came from outside.